black for a reason

what a spin

Sunday, November 16, 2008

Rocky Bru provided some of Dr. Mahathir's speech on Bangsa Malaysia.

Though many left comments in agreement with Dr. Mahathir, I beg to differ.



After March 8, we are more racial than ever. Former Prime Minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad has told those who say the last General Election was a vote to reject race-based parties and politics to stop deluding themselves. "We have become more racial than ever since the last General Election. We debate about race every day, more than before," he said. In an off-the-cuff lecture on Bangsa Malaysia in Putrajaya this morning, he said if the outcome of the March general election was a rejection of racial politics, there would be less talk about race today. Instead, race has become a central issue since March. That election has stimulated discussion about little else other than race.


I beg to differ, discussing racial issues and discriminating or systematically depriving certain races are two different thing. I still see certain party keep raising petty issues such as placing multi-lingual signboards while that party itself did similar things, in Arabic language. No offense to foreign "Visit Malaysia" Arabs, but hey, you did offended locals "Loyal Citizens" such as Chinese and Indians.



"And if PAS is not a race-based party, then I am not Mahathir Bin Mohamad," he said.
DAP not a race-based party? "Apart from some window-dressing, it's still the old DAP".
And PKR? "It is said to be Islamic, it's also pro-Hindraf, and pro-Chinese educationists. But that's because there is this man with many faces who leads the party. After him, who will lead the PKR? If it is led by a non-Malay, it will not have the support of the Malays."


Emm.... Mamak does qualify to join PAS... same applies to those loyal non-muslim supporters in their PAS Supporter Clubs. Wait a minute, do you mean only Malays can be Muslim? That's absurd to my knowledge.



Bangsa Malaysia without Bahasa Malaysia? Dr M also chided those who clamour for a Bangsa Malaysia but are unwilling to give due regards to the national language. These people, he said, should emulate Obama and children of migrant races in the US, Switzerland and Australia.

"Obama, who must be in some ways a descendant of a slave, is today US President. The blacks had tribes in Africa but after years in the US they all speak English. English is their mothertongue. The speak English at work, at school and at home. The same as the migrant Jews. They became naturalised American citizens. But they accpet that as Americans they must speak English."


I beg to differ, The States does not have an official language. In fact, Spanish language is the second-most common language, spoken by almost 30 million people (or 13% of the population) in 2005. [1] In fact, states such as Hawaii [2] and Louisiana [3] does have Hawaiian and French along with English as their official language.

In contrast of what Dr. M said, in 2000, the census bureau printed the standard census questionnaires in six languages: English, Spanish, Korean, Chinese (in traditional characters), Vietnamese, and Tagalog.

Though Seattle (not sleepless though) [1] did own a trash can with multilingual labels, I didn't see anyone carrying banners walking around crying outloud for injustice like mad dog.



I'm not Malay Malaysian. Dr M said Bangsa Malaysia exists but mostly among Malaysians abroad, he said. "I've met many Malaysians overseas. Those who approached me introduced themselves as Malaysians, not Chinese Malaysians or Indian Malaysians or Malay Malaysians. Just Malaysians.

"But back home here, they want to go to different schools."


I personally introduce myself as Malaysians. Full Stop. I'm not sure about your "friends" though. Vincent Tan, Eusoffe Chin, Lingam, etc.



Sekolah Wawasan. For a Bangsa Malaysia to be born, the current race-based schooling system must go. "This is the only country where we have different streams of schools: Chinese, Tamil and National schools. The Chinese educationists think their kids should not get any close to the kids from the national schools. Or they might turn into Chinese Mat rempits."

The idea of Sekolah Wawasan was to put the 3 schools in one campus. This will compel the children of different races to meet and interact with each other. Morning assembly would be held together. The pupils will be in one assembly. When they play, they'll play together. Not Chinese school vs National school.

"I must admit the Sekolah Wawasan concept did not get support, especially from the Chinese educationist groups. They don't want to have anything to do with the Malays."


True, we might be the only country with "streamlined" schools. Other countries just have schools with different language as medium of instruction, without any discrimination.


Heck, what a lousy spin.


PS: Aya.... I guess you're too old to bother to google or to check wikipedia...

Labels: ,




1 Comments (Post a Comment)

Anonymous Anonymous
10:25 PM


I would like to point out on 2 facts:
1) "We have become more racial than ever since the last General Election. We debate about race every day, more than before," he said

- Indeed because during HIS TIME, the issue wasn't talked about as much. So by comparison to HIS TIME, we're more? Yeah rite.
Also, debating race doesn't make us race based. Isn't that quite a leap?

2)"And if PAS is not a race-based party, then I am not Mahathir Bin Mohamad," he said

- Ok, maybe in some way since Malays are Muslims. But who again who made that into a law and expects that to be followed to the letter? I can't remember.

Will he ever keep his promise of "not saying anything after I leave"

Links to this post ( Create a Link)

Creative Commons License